WEQ Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force

Wholesale Electric

Retail Electric | Wholesale Gas | Retail Gas

Search | What's Hot? | Press Release | Home

WEQ Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force:

Please note that we have started posting all files in editable format. If you experience problems accessing the formatted document, please call the NAESB office (713-356-0060) and it will be provided to you in Adobe Acrobat (pdf) format.

Date	Event/Location	Agenda	Minutes	Misc.
August 19, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call With Web Conferencing	Revised Agenda	Draft Minutes Final IIPTF Report	Revised Draft IIPTF Report as of 8/4/05 Correspondence from NERC to Roy Thilly - 08/09/05
August 4, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Draft Minutes Revised Draft IIPTF Report	Revised Draft IIPTF Report Revised Draft IIPTF Report - modified 8/3/05 Comments Submitted by Mr. Henery Comments Submitted by Mr. Lively Comments Submitted by H. Illian R. Blohm Comments on the H. Illian Paper
July 21, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes Draft IIPTF Report	Revised Draft IIPTF Report WATEC Description Submitted by N. Henery Additional Information from M. Lively Proposed Redline Draft IIPTF Report, Submitted by R. Blohm
July 7, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call With Web Conferencing	Revised Agenda	Final Minutes IIPTF Draft Whitepaper with Changes	IIPTF White Paper
June 7, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call With Web Conferencing	Agenda CANCELLED
May 5, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 1 - Final IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 2 - Final	Draft Recommendation - 2003 WEQ Annual Plan Item 6 - IIP
May 4-5, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	CANCELLED		Nearby Hotels
April 12-13, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes Draft Recommendation - 2003 WEQ Annual Plan Item 6 - IIP	Nearby Hotels N. Henery-SMUD Response to WATEC Gaming Example Southwest Power Pool Inadvertent Management Business Practice WATEC Gaming Example IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 1 after 2/23/05 Meeting IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 2 after 2/23/05 Meeting
February 23-24, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 1 after 2/23/05 Meeting IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 2 after 2/23/05 Meeting	Nearby Hotels IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 1 IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 2 Inadvertent Management Business Practice WATEC Gaming Example
January 19-20, 2005	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes Attachment - IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 1 Attachment - IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 2	Nearby Hotels IIPTF Option 1 IIPTF Option 2 Comments on Option 1 Submitted by M.Lively Comments on Option 2 Submitted by M.Lively Comments on Option 2 Submitted by J. Tolo Comments on Option 1 Submitted by G. Locke Comments on Option 2 Submitted by G. Locke Comments on Option 1 Submitted by M. Potishnak Comments on Option 2 Submitted by M. Potishnak Comments on Option 1 Submitted by E. Howell Comments on Option 2 Submitted by E. Howell Comments on Option 2 Submitted by F. Halpin Comments on Option 1 Submitted by K. Tammar Comments on Option 2 Submitted by K. Tammar Comments on Option 1 Submitted by H. Illian Comments on Option 2 Submitted by H. Illian Comments on Option 1 and 2 Submitted by S. McKean Comments on Option 1 Submitted by R. Blohm Revised Comments on Option 2 Submitted by R. Blohm Comments on Option 2 Submitted by G. Brown (Received Late)
December 10, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Request for Comments due January 10, 2005		IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 1 - Final IIPTF Response to Comments on Option 2 - Final	IIPTF Option 1 IIPTF Option 1 Comment Form IIPTF Option 2 IIPTF Option 2 Comment Form IIPTF Request for Comments Comments on Option 1 Submitted by M.Lively Comments on Option 2 Submitted by M.Lively Comments on Option 2 Submitted by J. Tolo Comments on Option 1 Submitted by G. Locke Comments on Option 2 Submitted by G. Locke Comments on Option 1 Submitted by M. Potishnak Comments on Option 2 Submitted by M. Potishnak Comments on Option 1 Submitted by E. Howell Comments on Option 2 Submitted by E. Howell Comments on Option 2 Submitted by F. Halpin Comments on Option 1 Submitted by K. Tammar Comments on Option 2 Submitted by K. Tammar Comments on Option 1 Submitted by H. Illian Comments on Option 2 Submitted by H. Illian Comments on Option 1 and 2 Submitted by S. McKean Comments on Option 1 Submitted by R. Blohm Revised Comments on Option 2 Submitted by R. Blohm Comments on Option 2 Submitted by G. Brown (Received Late)
December 7-8, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes Attachment - IIPTF Option 1 Attachment - IIPTF Option 2	Nearby Hotels IIS Option 2 R1 - Enhancements Draft IIPTF Posting Letter Redline November 3-4, 2004 WEQ IIPTF Draft Minutes, Submitted by Robert Blohm IIS Option 1 Option 1 Supporting 1 Option 1 Supporting 2 Option 1 Draft 2 Option 2 Draft 2
November 3-4, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes Attachment - IIS Option 2 R1 - Enhancements Attachment - Draft IIPTF Posting Letter Attachment - IIS Option 1	Meeting Arrangements IIPTF IIS Option 1 IIPTF IIS Option 2 Draft Posting Letter
October 27, 2004	NERC Resources Subcommittee and NAESB IIPTF Meeting Reno, NV Held at Harrah's Hotel Reno	Agenda		RS IITF SAR R2 Inadvertent Interchange White Paper IIPTF IIS Option 2 Final Modified Conforming WECC Auto Time Error Correction to CPS Submitted by H.Illian WECC WATEC to CPS Interpretation IIPTF Revised Strawman, Version 3 Unscheduled Power Crisis: R.Blohm "Public Utilities Fortnightly" article WECC Payback Formula Submitted by BPA IIPTF IIS Option 1
October 19-20, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes IIPTF IIS Option 2 Final IIPTF IIS Option 1	WECC Payback Formula Submitted by BPA IIPTF IIS Option 2 Final Modified Conforming WECC Auto Time Error Correction to CPS submitted by H.Illian Modified Practical Meaning of Conforming WECC Auto Time Error Correction to CPS submitted by R.Blohm Meeting Arrangements Redlined September 22-23, 2004 Draft Minutes Submitted by R.Blohm IIPTF Revised Strawman, Version 3 Ratio Example for Inadvertent Settlement
September 22-23, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB office, 23rd Floor With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes	Nearby Hotels Conforming WECC Auto Time Error Correction to CPS submitted by H.Illian Practical Meaning of Conforming WECC Auto Time Error Correction to CPS submitted by R.Blohm BPA Comments on WECC ATEC Questions Submitted by F.Halpin IIPTF Revised Strawman, Version 3
August 25-26, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Colorado Springs, CO Hosted by El Paso Corporation Room 237	Agenda	Final Minutes	Meeting Arrangements Redlined July 26-27 Draft Minutes Submitted by N. Henery Redlined July 26-27 Draft Minutes Submitted by R.Blohm IIPTF Revised Strawman, Version 3 Strawman Drafted by N.Henery WECC Link for IIPTF Efforts
August 13, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call With Web Conferencing	Agenda	Final Minutes	IIPTF Revised Strawman, Version 3 Strawman Drafted by N.Henery
July 26-27, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Las Vegas, NV Held at the Luxor Hotel	Agenda	Final Minutes Resulting Strawman	Comments on July 1, 2004 IIPTF Draft Minutes Submitted by R.Blohm Comments on Section 8 from P.Cox IIPTF Revised Strawman, Version 3 Redlined Minutes of July 13, 2004 Meeting Presentation - CMOPS Report SMUD Submitted by N.Henery Flow Chart Submitted by J. Power
July 13, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Agenda	Final Minutes IIPTF Revised Strawman, Version 3	R.Blohm Picture of How Many Hours of Inadvertent Interchange is outside Deadbands R.Blohm Picture of How Much of the MWh of Inadvertent Interchange is outside Deadbands R.Blohm Picture of Continuous Deadband Updated IIPTF Strawman, Version 2
July 1, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Agenda	Final Minutes Updated IIPTF Strawman, Version 2	Standard for Inadvertent Interchange Payback - Eastern Interconnection Method Submitted by N.Henery Updated Draft IIPTF Strawman Comment by R.Blohm to Updated Draft IIPTF Strawman
June 23-24, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB Office, 23rd Floor	Agenda	Final Minutes	Nearby Hotels Inadvertent Settlement Proposal, R1 - Submitted by T.Vandervort Assuring Balanced Settlement for Inadvertent Interchange - Submitted by H.Illian Only Native Prices Properly Signal Inadvertent Congestion - Submitted by H.Illian and R.Blohm Hourly Frequency Error Probability Plot Submitted by T. Bilke Draft IIPTF Strawman IIPTF Strawman Submitted by Larry M. Goins Comments by R. Blohm on Preliminary IIPTF Strawman
May 26-27, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB Office, 23rd Floor	Agenda	IIPTF Substantive Motions as of March 8, 2004 Final Minutes Attachment 1 - IIPTF Substantive Motions as of May 26-27, 2004	R.Blohm Comment: Crisis of Inadvertent Interchange Parking and Upward Frequency Drift Solved only by Frequency Adder N. Henery: Draft NAESB Standard for Inadvertent Interchange Payback (IIP) Western Interconnection (WI) Method J. Power: Nb Nearby Hotels
May 5-6, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Juno Beach, FL Hosted by Florida Power & Light	Agenda	Final Minutes	Meeting Arrangements R. Blohm: Simple Frequency Adder WECC Procedure for Time Error Control Description of Area Control Error (ACE) Calculation Strawman: Inadvertent Interchange Payback Strawman: Inadvertent Interchange for Public Posting Strawman: NAESB "On-Peak" and "Off-Peak" Periods R.Blohm: Adder & Deadband Comment D. Hils Letter to NERC Submitted by R. Blohm D. Hils Eastern Interconnection Frequency Error Spreadsheet Submitted by R.Blohm
April 1-2, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB Office, 23rd Floor	Revised Agenda - Please note new end time for day 2	IIPTF Substantive Motions as of March 8, 2004 Final Minutes	Nearby Hotels R. Blohm Motion: Sending FCC back to NERC R. Blohm Comment: Problems with Zonal Energy Pricing and with Reliability Deadband A. DiCaprio Motion Blohm Comments on DiCaprio Motion Letter to S. Terelmes Submitted by M. Lively Native-Market-Pricing for Inadvertent Interchange Submitted by H. Illian March 12, 2004 WEQ EC Draft Minutes WEQ MOS IIPTF Draft Outline for Standard Draft Report of the IIPTF to the WEQ EC T.Vandervort Motion Frequency Data
February 26-27, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB Office, 23rd Floor	Agenda	IIPTF Substantive Motions as of February 17, 2004 Final Minutes	Nearby Hotels R.Blohm Bilateral Fin. Settlement Alternative R.Blohm Response to Single-Price Method M. Lively's WOLF Methodology R.Blohm Comment: Power/MISO Motion Causes Underfrequency
January 22-23, 2004	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Dallas, TX Hosted by AEP	Revised Agenda with corrected meeting times	IIPTF Substantive Motions as of January 20, 2004 Final Minutes	Meeting Arrangements M. Lively Motions for Consideration A. DiCaprio Note on Inadvertent A. DiCaprio Supplemental H. Illian Response to A. DiCaprio Recent Inadvertent Interchange Energy Pricing Alternatives Economist's comments on Matrix of Outcomes for 5 Different Ways of Settling the Energy Component of Inadvertent Interchange including DiCaprio/PJM Proposal in blue Matrix of Outcomes for 5 Different Ways of Settling the Energy Component of Inadvertent Interchange including DiCaprio/PJM proposal R. Blohm Response to A. DiCaprio Working Paper by M. Lively Working Paper by T. Reed JIITF White Paper Summary
December 10-11, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB Office	Agenda	Final Minutes (12/11/03) Final Minutes - Revised (12/10/03)	Nearby Hotels Correspondence from S.Terelmes, IIPTF Co-Chair R.Blohm Presentation (PowerPoint Format) R.Blohm Presentation (Adobe Format) M.Lively Presentation (PowerPoint Format) M.Lively Presentation (Adobe Format) H. Illian Presentation H. Illian Supplement 1 H. Illian Supplement 2 H. Illian Supplement 3 H. Illian Supplement 4 H. Illian Supplement 5 H. Illian Supplement 6
November 3, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Held at the NAESB Office	Agenda	Final Minutes	Nearby Hotels L. Goins Motion for Consideration H. Illian Response to L.Goins Motion R. Blohm Response to L. Goins Motion
October 8, 2003 Please note this meeting has been rescheduled for October 6	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Tempe, AZ	RESCHEDULED TO OCTOBER 6
October 6, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Tempe, AZ	Agenda	Final Minutes Detailed Voting Record	Meeting Arrangements Letter from the IIPTF Chairman S. Terelmes Motions for Consideration M. Lively Motions for Consideration R. Blohm Motions for Consideration
September 15-16, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Austin, TX Held at the Driskill Hotel	Agenda	Final Minutes	Meeting Arrangements Redlined Draft Minutes from 8/6/03 Submitted by Robert Blohm WECC Auto Time Error - Progress Report September, 2003 WECC Auto Time Error Correction Posting/Agenda Policy for IIPTF Meetings Blohm-Frequency Control Contribution of Inadvertent (Adobe Acrobat Format) Blohm-Frequency Control Contribution of Inadvertent (PowerPoint Format) R.Blohm response to W.McReynolds M. Lively Response to R. Blohm
August 20, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Agenda	Final Minutes	Comments Submitted by Robert Blohm 1 - Not "Bilateral" Inadvertent, but Inadvertent "with the (rest of the) Interconnection" represents the true SOURCES and SINKS of Inadvertent... Comments Submitted by Mark Lively Response to Mark Lively's Comments by Robert Blohm Comments Submitted by Robert Blohm on Amended Schedule 4 Tariffs as a default for spot energy market price Comments Submitted by Robert Blohm on Decomposing RTOs/ISOs, not Bilateralizing Inadvertents Comments Submitted by Robert Blohm - Bilateralizing Inadvertents violates Flow-Path Comments Submitted by Robert Blohm - WOLF contradicts Tie-Line Bias Control Comments Submitted by Bonneville Power Admin. - Schedule 4 and Business Practices for Energy Imbalance and Generation Imbalance Comments Submitted by Bonneville Power Admin. - Proposal for the Pricing/Return of Imbalance Energy for the Next Rate Period
August 6, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Philadelphia, PA Hosted by PECO	Agenda	Final Minutes	Work Paper Submitted by Robert Blohm - Default Pricing of the Energy Component of Inadvertent Interchange Presentation by Mark Lively Work Paper Submitted by Mark Lively - Profit-Enhancing Seam Management Work Paper Submitted by Mark Lively - MISO-CMWG Sample Tariff Imbalance Charges Revised Submitted Comments by Robert Blohm on Default Pricing of the Energy Component of Inadvertent Interchange Redlined July 9, 2003 Draft Minutes Submitted by Robert Blohm Redlined June 18, 2003 Draft Minutes Submitted by Robert Blohm
August 4, 2003	NERC/NAESB IIPTF Organizational Meeting Philadelphia, PA Held at the Crowne Plaza City Center Hotel	Agenda	Revised Meeting Notes	Meeting Arrangements Comments Submitted by Tom Vandervort
July 23, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Revised Agenda	Final Minutes
July 9, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Colorado Springs, CO Hosted by El Paso Western Pipelines	Agenda	Final Minutes Attachment 1	Meeting Arrangements Revised Outline for Standard - Version 2 The MISO Questions with Answers MISO Inadvertent Draft Two-Fold Task of Inadvertent Pricing Submitted by Robert Blohm Inadvertent and Settlement Presentation Submitted by the Midwest ISO Locational-Pricing for Inadvertent Interchange Current NERC Operating Manual Policy 1 Inadvertent Interchange Requirements Inadvertent Interchange Frequency Control Component Presentation Frequency Control Contribution Graph 3 Golden Rules of Inadvertent Interchange Accounting
June 18, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Agenda	Final Minutes Attachment 1 - IIPTF Draft Outline for Standard Attachment 2 - Questions for IIPTF	Questions Submitted by the Midwest ISO NERC-MISO-PJM Inadvertent Waiver Submitted by AEP NERC Waiver - Financial Inadvertent Settlement Submitted by AEP NAESB WEQ MOS IIPTF Draft Outline for Standard Comments Submitted by Robert Blohm Waiver Request - Scheduling Agent Waiver Request - Tagging Dynamic Schedules and Inadvertent Payback
June 4, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Washington, DC Hosted by EEI	Agenda	Final Minutes	Meeting Arrangements Pricing Summary IISP Definition IIPTF Reference Paper Robert Blohm's Comments to the IIPTF Reference Paper Work Paper Submitted by Robert Blohm - self-explanatory version
May 8, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Hosted by NAESB	Agenda	Final Minutes Attachment - Workpaper Corrected on 5/8/03	Nearby Hotels Inadvertent Interchange Energy Price Work Paper Submitted by Howard Illian WEQ IIPTF Report Work Paper Submitted by Robert Blohm - self-explanatory version
April 29, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Houston, TX Hosted by NAESB	Agenda	Final Minutes	Nearby Hotels Work Paper Submitted by AEP Work Paper Submitted by Allegheny Power - ECAR Inadvertent Settlement Tariff Work Paper Submitted by Allegheny Power - FERC Order
April 9, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Ft. Lauderdale, FL Held at the Riverside Hotel	Agenda	Final Minutes	Work Paper from Robert Blohm Work Paper from Howard Illian
March 31, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Agenda	Final Minutes	Work Paper Submitted by Robert Blohm Re: Avg Freq Error
February 27, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Agenda	Final Minutes Attachment - Standards Request	Draft Standards Request PJM/MISO Congestion Management Seams Issue Whitepaper
February 19, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force New Orleans, LA Wyndham New Orleans Hotel	Agenda	Final Minutes Draft Standards Request	Hotel Directions Defining Good and Bad Inadvertent Energy Mark Discussion on the Nature of the Inadvertent Problem NERC Appendix 1F - Inadvertent Interchange Dispute Resolution Process NERC Inadvertent Interchange Economics Report
February 13, 2003	Inadvertent Interchange Payback Task Force Conference Call	Agenda	Redlined Draft Minutes	Work Paper 1 - Submitted by Robert Blohm Background Information from NERC Request Work Papers NERC Support Documents

If you should encounter any problems or need further information, please call (713) 356-0060.
About NAESB | Contact NAESB | Email: naesb@naesb.org | Home Page